“I heard the smoke alarm. I ran in there when I heard it!” She hadn’t been in there because she set the fire.
“You didn’t see anyone in there?” His eyes glinted in the setting sun. “Think, Heather. We lost all the evidence we had. The FBI agents are gone, and this is on us. On our watch. We already look bad enough to the public. I can’t have someone saying Marsh has an accomplice in my station, someone trying to cover up for the man even after he’s dead.”
He’s dead. The pain hit her again, stark and brutal, seeming to drive right into her heart.
“Sir, it wasn’t me.” She fought to keep her voice steady. “I didn’t see anyone. I’m sorry.”
If only she had.
“Maybe it was just an accident.” He paced a few feet away from her. “The fire department will be able to tell us. They’ll investigate. Maybe Danielle’s equipment got too hot.”
“Maybe,” Heather whispered. She wasn’t convinced.
Not convinced at all.
He slanted her a long, hard look, then rubbed his chest. Just above his heart, as if he hurt, too. “You need to go home, Heather. Get some rest.”
But home was empty. Silent.
Home made her think too much.
She frowned at the hand on his chest. “Captain, are you okay?”
“I’m fine.” But he sounded tired. “Hell, I’m heading home. Maybe tomorrow, we’ll wake up, and things will be different.”
She watched him walk away.
She opened the station’s back door. As she stepped inside, the scent of smoke seemed even stronger now.
Heather hurried past the damaged room. She should call the FBI agents. Tell them what happened. When they found out, they were going to be so pissed.
Small-town office screws up again.
Cadence’s fingers curled around the small business card that had been hidden in the bottom drawer. Her card.
She remembered giving it to Susannah, and hoping—hoping—the woman would call her with news.
Only Susannah had never called.
Right then, Cadence’s phone began to vibrate in her pocket.
Her left hand cradled the card as her right lifted the phone. “Hollow.”
“The tapes burned.”
She frowned. The connection was horrible. She could barely hear. “Heather? Is that you?”
“There was a fire at the station. All of the tapes burned.” Heather’s words tumbled out.
Cadence actually felt her heart stop at that news. No, no! If the tapes were burned, then that meant their evidence was gone. Her heart started to beat again, at a double-time rate. Cadence glanced down at the card in her hand. If only Susannah had called her…
“I think you should get back here,” Heather whispered. “If Jason was the killer, then how could a dead man start a fire?”
He couldn’t. But a live killer could.
Kyle led the way into the station, rushing down to the evidence room. The tapes were gone, but they still had the remains—the bones.
And Maria’s necklace.
He pounded his hand against the heavy door that secured the evidence room. “Kyle…” There was a warning edge to Cadence’s voice.
He slanted her a fast look. “I have to see it.” Every instinct in his body was screaming at him right then.
The door opened with a groan of sound. Morty Adams, the evidence clerk, frowned at them. “Wh-what’s happening, agents?”
“You heard about the fire.” Not a question.
But Morty nodded. “I—I had to evacuate when the firefighters came in. We all had to leave…”
And that would have meant this room wasn’t secured.
If Maria was his first victim, she’d be special. The one he wanted to hold on to for the longest.
“Get the necklace that was recovered from the caves.”
Morty’s eyes widened and he stumbled back, hurrying to obey.
“You think it was a distraction,” Cadence said as her shoulder brushed against his.
“It could have been.” A fire to draw away the attention of everyone while the killer went after what he really wanted.
Killers and their keepsakes. Their tokens.
A token from the guy’s very first kill…
You’d want it back.
“It could just have been an accident,” Cadence said. “You heard what Dani said. Shelly was aiming at Jason.”
He wasn’t so sure.
Morty came back. Breath heaving. “I-it’s gone.”
Sonofabitch.
“It was here earlier, I swear it was!” Morty’s cheeks flushed dark red. “I showed it to James. We secured it. It was here.”
Why would James want to see that necklace?
“Someone had to take it while I was outside. During the fire…”
“And dead men don’t set fires,” Cadence whispered.
Footsteps sounded behind them. Kyle whirled around.
Heather paused on the stairs.
“Where’s the captain?” Cadence asked her.
Heather licked her lips. “He…ah…he went home. He hasn’t been feeling so good these past few months.”
Kyle forced his jaw to unclench. “Shelly—Susannah—she was holding a gun to your head.”
Heather flinched, but nodded.
“So you had the same view she did,” Cadence whispered.
Another rough nod. “Sh-she shot James.”
So they all knew, but what they didn’t know… “Was anyone else standing near Detective Marsh?”
“The agent. Dani.” Heather’s gaze lowered to the floor. Then she exhaled and straightened her shoulders. She glanced back at Kyle. Then Cadence. “And the captain.”
Sonofa—
“I saw him running up, right behind Jason. They were both there when Susannah Jane fired the shot.”
The captain. The captain. The man who’d been free when the fire was set. The man who’d come to see the necklace.
The man who’d huddled so closely over Susannah Jane in her last moments.
“That bullet wasn’t meant for Jason.” Cadence had turned toward Kyle.
His heartbeat drummed in his ears. “It was meant for Anniston.” The man who’d been there, from day one. The man who’d helped him search for Maria. The man who’d known every single step that their investigation had taken.
“Heather, are you sure he was going home?”
“Th-that’s what he said.”
Home.
Kyle glanced out of the narrow window. Saw the darkness spreading over the sky. “I want you to get some officers and go search his house.”