This letter has been on quite a trip.
I slid my finger under the flap and ripped open the top of the envelope to find the letter inside was in no better shape. Stained from coffee and dirt, it was unreadable, except for one line at the bottom that read in part, "Don't ignore this warning..." I strained to understand the words that came after, but the abuse the letter had endured made it impossible to figure out its meaning through the smeared ink.
Turning the envelope and letter over, I saw nothing more. Sure it was a debt collection letter for some bill I'd forgotten, I dismissed the piece of mail and threw it all in the garbage, along with the alumni and junk mail.
The last envelope in the pile sat waiting for me. I picked it up and examined it, noticing it had the same handwritten address and post office mark on the front of the envelope, but it had been mailed only the day before. At least the mailman hadn't put this one through the wringer. Tearing it open, I unfolded the letter inside and began reading.
The words swam in front of my eyes. Your father. They got away with murder. Ask Tristan. He knows who's responsible. My hands began to tremble violently, and I threw the paper away from me. Shaking my head in disbelief, I struggled to hold back the tears.
It wasn't possible. There was no way Tristan was involved in my father's murder. He couldn't be. He didn't even know him.
As I repeated those words again and again in my head, I realized I couldn't be sure he hadn't known him. I knew very little about Tristan before just a few months ago. What if the person who'd written this letter was right?
My head felt like it was beginning to spin, like everything around me was spiraling out of control. My mind raced to find any sign that the accusation made in the letter was correct. Every word he'd said suddenly became suspect, every action confirmation of his guilt.
My stomach tied itself into knots as every moment we'd spent together played out in my mind. Why had he wanted someone like me in the first place? Why had he pushed for me to live here with him? Did the phone calls he'd begun receiving right around the time I should have received the first letter have anything to do with this? I didn't want to believe I was in danger, but for the first time since I'd met Tristan, I was truly frightened.
"Where were we?"
I looked up and saw him standing in the doorway, a look of concern of his face like he always had after taking one of those phone calls. But now he looked different. Foreign.
"Nina, what's wrong? You look like you've seen a ghost."
Staring at the letter that lay near the edge of the bed, I reached over and picked it up. "Tell me you had nothing to do with my father's death. Tell me whoever wrote this letter is simply being cruel."
Tristan's face grew ashen as he stood staring at me, his eyes wide. "What are you talking about?"
"This letter. Someone says you know who killed my father. Do you?" My voice cracked as I pleaded for his answer.
He walked toward me and tried to take the letter from my hand. "What are you saying?"
Jumping to my feet, I pulled the letter from his hold and pressed it close to my chest. "Do you know who killed my father? Tell me!"
"Nina, calm down. Let me see the letter."
I backed away from him, shaking my head. "No! Just answer the fucking question! Do you know anything about who murdered my father?"
His silence was deafening as he remained staring at me, hurt filling his eyes.
"Oh, my God! You do!" I cried. "How could you? Get away from me!"
He followed me and gently touched my arm. "Nina, it's not what you think. Calm down and take a seat."
Pushing his hand away, I screamed, "I will not calm down! Tell me what you know! Who killed my father?"
"Please sit down. I promise you I had nothing to do with your father's death."
Tears rolled down my cheeks as I let him lead me over to the bed. I wanted so much to believe he hadn't been a part of taking my father away from me. Tristan was the man of my dreams and now it seemed like everything we'd had was tainted by this one letter.
I sat down on the edge of the bed and watched him kneel down in front of me, just like he had days earlier when he'd made me the happiest woman in the world. He looked up at me with those brown eyes that spoke volumes even before the first world left his mouth.